Completing the trine: Which are the safest fats?

First, watch this video by Chris Masterjohn.

Diets very high in pufas (polyunsaturates) are not beneficial to heart health or longevity. Flora? No thanks!

Here's a chart. The beige & grey bars represent pufas (omega-6 & omega-3).

Comparison of dietary fats

The yellow bars represent monounsaturates and the orangey-red bars represent saturates. I consider these to be harmless, as long as you don't go mad and eat them in such large amounts that you gain weight.

Bearing in mind the information in the video, plus the information in Fats: Spawn of Satan or Dogs' Doodads? , I use only fats from the bottom 6 for cooking (olive oil and butter, actually).

Flaxseed oil can be used as an omega-3 supplement for vegetarian/vegan women, as omega-3 pufas are as rare as rocking-horse poo in most foods (apart from oily fish).

Non-vegetarian/vegan people can get their long-chain omega-3 pufas (EPA & DHA) from oily fish. As vegetarian/vegan men barely produce any DHA from the omega-3 in flaxseed oil, they should get it from algal DHA supplements. See Extremely Limited Synthesis of Long Chain Polyunsaturates in Adults: Implications for their Dietary Essentiality and use as Supplements.

Ban Butter, Part 4,400?

By the time I've finished typing this, there will probably be over 4,400 blogs containing the phrase "Ban Butter". I'm not going to call Shyam Kolvekar rude names. He's a heart surgeon so he's probably very good at cutting people's chests open, removing clogged coronary arteries and grafting in veins removed from legs or whatever it is they do. I don't really wanna know!

He obviously doesn't read our blogs, or he wouldn't have said what he did. If he didn't get any money from Unilever for saying it, that's rather foolish. If I'm going to risk being called every rude name under the sun, I want it to be worth my while.

Anyway, in case you missed it, here's Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease.

See also Fats and Fatty Acids in Human Nutrition and specifically Dietary Fat and Coronary Heart Disease: Summary of Evidence from Prospective Cohort and Randomised Controlled Trials.

I personally use Anchor Spreadable (kept in the 'fridge) or Anchor/Kerrygold (kept out of the 'fridge) as they're from grass-fed cows.

Finally, for a little light relief, see Butter vs Margarine.

Update: From Hartke Is Online!

Fats: Spawn of Satan or Dogs' Doodads?

Fats get a lot of bad press in the media. There are so many adverts with "X% fat-free" or "only 1g of fat per Jaffa Cake" as if that's going to stop you from getting fat when you "om nom nom" your way through a whole box of the things!

Saturated fats are usually described as "bad" and polyunsaturates are usually described as "good". This is simplistic. Everything is bad in excess, even polyunsaturates. The thing about fats is that there are four basic types (saturates, monounsaturates, omega-6 polyunsaturates and omega-3 polyunsaturates) and they need to be consumed in roughly the right proportions for optimum health. Suffice it to say, the majority of people in the West do not eat them in anywhere near the right proportions. So, what exactly are fats?

Fats

Fats are an ester of glycerol and three fatty acids and are also known as triglycerides or triacylglycerols.

1 molecule of glycerol + 3 molecules of fatty acid = 1 molecule of triglyceride + 3 molecules of water.

It's the fatty acids that determine whether a fat is sat, mono etc. The four different types of fatty acid all have a CH3 at one end and a COOH at the other. The difference is in the middle section.

Saturated fatty acids have a middle section consisting of all CH2's. Here's a diagram for Stearic acid (the predominant fatty acid in beef):-

__H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H OH-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H__H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H HMonounsaturated fatty acids have one C=C bond in the middle, which is usually (but not always) 9 from the left-hand end resulting in monounsaturates usually being referred to as omega-9's, as omega is the letter at the end of the Greek alphabet. Here's a diagram for Oleic acid (the predominant fatty acid in olive oil):-

__H H H H H H H H_____H H H H H H H OH-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C=C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H__H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H

Omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids have two or more C=C bonds in the middle with the last one always being 6 from the left-hand end. Here's a diagram for Linoleic acid (the predominant fatty acid in sunflower oil):-

__H H H H H_____H_____H H H H H H H OH-C-C-C-C-C-C=C-C-C=C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H
__H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H

Omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids have three or more C=C bonds in the middle with the last one always being 3 from the left-hand end. Here's a diagram for Alpha-linolenic acid (the predominant fatty acid in flax-seed oil):-

__H H_____H_____H_____H H H H H H H OH-C-C-C=C-C-C=C-C-C=C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H__H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H

These diagrams are slightly misleading. Where there is a C=C bond, there are two H's on the "underside" only of the molecule. This asymmetry causes the H's to repel each other and bend the molecule into a V-shape at each C=C bond. C=C bonds with H's on the same side are known as "cis" bonds. The above molecule is really cis, cis, cis (c,c,c) Alpha-linolenic acid. The other type of C=C bond is known as "trans" and looks like the following diagram:-

__H H H___H H___H H___H H H H H H H OH-C-C-C=C-C-C=C-C-C=C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H
__H H___H H___H H___H H H H H H H H

This is a diagram of trans, trans, trans (t,t,t) Alpha-linolenic acid. As the H's are on opposite sides of the molecule, they do not repel each other and the molecule is straight as shown above. Note that saturated fatty acid molecules are naturally straight. Therein lies the problem with trans-fatty acids. They're straight, like saturated fatty acids but have unsaturated bonds which are prone to oxidation. See http://www.cyberlipid.org/perox/oxid0002.htm WARNING! Heavy-duty organic chemistry!

Our bodies take trans-fatty acids and incorporate them into cell membranes as if they were saturated fatty acids. This results in atherogenicity (artery-clogging), damage to the immune system and other health problems. Trans-fatty acids are found in partially-hydrogenated vegetable oils and so any processed foods or cooking/spreading fats which has the word "hydrogenated" high-up in the ingredients list should be avoided. These truly are bad fats. There are also naturally-occurring trans-fatty acids made by bacteria in the stomachs of ruminant animals, like Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA). This looks a bit like the diagram below:-

__H H H H H_____H___H H H H H H H H O
H-C-C-C-C-C-C=C-C=C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-C-O-H
__H H H H H H H___H H H H H H H H H

This has one of the C=C bonds shifted to the left and also has one cis bond and one trans bond, so the molecule is always bent. CLA has possibly beneficial properties but medical studies show mixed results. It's certainly not artery-clogging, so don't let anyone put you off eating butter from grass-fed cows (e.g. New Zealand butter) by saying that it has trans-fats in it. CLA is a harmless trans-fat.

Anyway, back to diet. Saturated fat consumption should be about 10% of total calories. This is because, even though sat fats are not essential (our bodies can manufacture them), this guarantees adequate levels of sex hormones in the body. Total polyunsaturate consumption should be about 5% of total calories, with a ratio of omega-6 (O6) to omega-3 (O3) of between 1:2 and 4:1. As O3's are only found in greater quantities than O6's in flax-seeds (a.k.a. linseeds) and oily fish, and many people eat way too little or no oily fish (and who, other than body-builders and some vegetarians/vegans, eats flax-seeds?), the O6:O3 ratio in the West is about 20:1. This is due to the widespread consumption of meats, eggs & milk from grain-fed animals, grains, nuts and seeds. So, it’s not surprising that there are high rates of heart disease and other inflammatory diseases in the West, as O6's end up in series 1 & 2 prostaglandins and series 2 prostaglandins are pro-inflammatory. O3 fats end up in series 3 prostaglandins, which are anti-inflammatory.

So eat up yer oily fish if you're not vegetarian or vegan. Otherwise, eat up yer ground-up flax-seeds!

Monounsaturates can make up 15% to 35% of total calories, depending on activity levels. Remember from the histogram in the Blog post Everyone is Different, sedentary people on average burn twice as much energy from fats as from carbs. So, if energy from protein is 25% say, 25% of energy can come from carbs and 50% can come from fats i.e. a 2:1 ratio of fats:carbs. The cyclists at the left-hand end of the histogram in Chapter 1 would do best on 25% protein, 5% carbs, 70% fat when sedentary, whereas the cyclist at the right-hand end of the histogram would do best on 25% protein, 60% carbs, 15% fat when sedentary. When active, more carbs are needed by everyone.

Which fats contain which fatty acids? See http://homepage.ntlworld.com/nigel.kinbrum/comparison-of-fats.gif for a Comparison of Dietary Fats chart. Click http://www.apag.org/oleo/fatsoils.pdf for tables of Properties & Composition of Vegetable & Special Oils and Properties & Composition of Animal & Marine Fats & Oils.

For high-temperature cooking, saturates are the least likely to oxidise (when they're on fire, they're oxidising!), followed by monos, then omega-6's with omega-3's being the least stable. An oil doesn't have to be smoking to be oxidising. Alpha-linolenic acid oxidises at room temperature, which is why linseed oil is used to varnish cricket bats and soften putty. The best non-animal fat for high-temperature cooking is Coconut Oil, followed by Palm Oil and then Olive Oil. Extra-Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) has a lower smoking temperature than refined Olive Oil (due to higher levels of free fatty acids), but has higher levels of polyphenol antioxidants, which makes it pretty heart-healthy.

Oils high in polyunsaturates shouldn't be heated above 100°C, as polyunsaturates can change from the cis configuration to the trans configuration at temperatures as low as 102°C. See http://www.harricksci.com/sites/default/files/pdf/application_notes/FatIR_App-Notes_ATR_Oil-Analysis.pdf